Babcock Dairy Recalls Orange Custard Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Peanut Butter Due to Undeclared Egg

Raleigh, N.C., Jan. 14, 2026 — Babcock Dairy of Madison, Wisconsin, has recalled approximately 41 cases of ice cream after discovering that Chocolate Peanut Butter containers were inadvertently filled with Orange Custard Chocolate Chip, creating an undeclared egg and tartrazine (Yellow #5) allergen risk. Consumers who are allergic or highly sensitive to eggs or Yellow #5 should stop using the product immediately and not eat it, as consumption could cause serious or life‑threatening allergic reactions.

The affected items are Orange Custard Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Peanut Butter half‑gallon containers from production date lot code(s) 09 1724 (produced Sept. 17, 2024). They have been sold since Sept. 17, 2024, online and at select U.S. retailers, and were distributed to local Madison, Wisconsin, retail establishments and direct customers; consumers should check the lot code on the bottom of the container to confirm whether their product is included in the recall.

Consumers in possession of impacted product are advised to stop use and return the container to the place of purchase for a full refund or dispose of it following local guidance; customers who cannot return the product should contact Babcock Dairy to request a refund or replacement and for additional instructions. Questions and refund or replacement requests may be directed to Casey Whyte, Plant Manager, at (608) 262‑9102 (6 a.m.–2 p.m. Monday–Friday) or by emailing [email protected]. Consumers should also consult the retailer or manufacturer website for updates and verification if contact information is not available.